SAC.Shock Move in Texas: Trump–Vance Administration Goes After Revered Nun, Then Hits Catholic Charities
Thank you for reading! Letters from Leo is a reader-supported publication. If you find value in my work, please consider becoming a paid subscriber or making a one-time donation.
Prefer A One-Time Gift? Donate Here
It started with ICE agents haunting church parking lots. It might end with padlocks on Catholic shelter doors.
Over the past year, the Trump-Vance White House has ratcheted up a campaign against the Catholic Church’s work with immigrants.
The latest target is Catholic Charities of the Rio Grande Valley (CCRGV) in South Texas, which runs a famed humanitarian respite center for migrant families.
The Department of Homeland Security has suspended this Catholic charity from all federal funding and moved to debar it for six years — an unusually harsh penalty.
DHS claims an audit found “pervasive” grant reporting violations, like inconsistent migrant records and billing outside allowed timeframes.
Officials accuse the charity, led by Sister Norma Pimentel, , of mishandling data so badly they couldn’t verify if some people served had ever appeared in DHS databases.
Sister Norma, nationally known as the immigrants’ nun, flatly rejects any suggestion of wrongdoing.
“Those on the front lines of our humanitarian outreach know the work we do truly helps to restore human dignity,” she said, adding that she “takes very seriously every single dollar entrusted to us.”
Her team notes that every person they aid has been processed and released by U.S. Border Patrol — they are simply caring for folks whom the government itself brought to the shelter.
CCRGV has pledged to work with DHS to resolve any concerns.
Yet the Trump-Vance White House barreled ahead with a suspension that could choke off the ministry’s primary resources within weeks.
Why such a heavy-handed response? Catholic leaders nationwide smell a rat. To them, this is not about spreadsheets or A-numbers at all — it’s payback.
The White House has long viewed Sister Norma’s operation as a thorn in its side, complaining that her shelter “encourages illegal immigration.”
Now, under the pretext of auditing “misconduct,” the administration is punishing one of the Church’s most visible border missions.
“It’s 100% a pretext for political reprisal,” one American bishop told me.
In their view, Trump and Vance are sending a chilling message to Catholics: if you dare defy our immigration agenda, we will make you pay (literally).
The extreme nature of the penalty bolsters this theory — federal debarments usually last three years, not six.
Freezing a charity’s funds for that long, especially one the White House openly criticized as too welcoming to migrants, looks less like routine oversight and more like a vendetta.
If the Trump-Vance administration expected the Church to roll over, they miscalculated. Instead, they have provoked one of the most unified Catholic counter-offensives in recent memory.
Bishops are reacting with outrage.
Back in February, when the new administration abruptly halted refugee resettlement funds, the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops took the extraordinary step of suing the federal government.
The bishops accused the White House of violating the the Constitution by usurping Congress’s approved funding.
That funding freeze — enacted in the name of a “90-day review” — forced Catholic Charities agencies from Florida to Kansas to lay off staff and shut down decades-old programs almost overnight.
“Brutal” and “unlawful” were the words Catholic leaders used as they went to court, arguing that the government’s actions harmed thousands of legally-admitted refugees and undermined the Church’s mission to “promote the dignity of the human person, especially the most vulnerable.”
That fighting spirit has only intensified in the face of the South Texas debacle. Multiple bishops and Catholic activists have denounced the funding cut-off as a naked act of anti-Catholic retribution.
Even Cardinal Timothy Dolan of New York — who pointedly prayed at Trump’s inauguration — blasted Vice President Vance’s smear of Church ministries earlier this year as “scurrilous… nasty and not true.”
Dolan and others recognize that the White House is tapping into old anti-Catholic tropes, painting the Church’s charity as suspect. Far from intimidating the clergy into silence, it has ignited them.
The entire U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, along with Catholic Charities USA, is standing firm.
This week in Washington, Church representatives delivered a 14-page letter to the administration “strongly oppos(ing)” its anti-migrant measures — from revoked work permits to the very funding assaults now underway.
They warned of “widespread…destabilizing” consequences for families and local communities if these policies persist.
The bishops are not mincing words: the government’s cruelty toward immigrants is a direct attack on human dignity, and the Church will not be complicit.
Above all, Pope Leo XIV himself has been a moral bulwark throughout these battles.
The first American pontiff has not stayed on the sidelines. In late October, Leo delivered one of the most searing rebukes of government injustice ever heard from a Pope.
He condemned the mistreatment of immigrants as “grave crimes… committed or tolerated by the state.”
He warned that “inhuman measures — even celebrated politically — treat these ‘undesirables’ as if they were garbage and not human beings.”
It was a thinly veiled indictment of Trump’s approach. And it put the Church unmistakably on record: welcoming the stranger is not optional, it’s a Christian mandate.
Pope Leo has gone further by explicitly praising and encouraging the very ministries now under fire.
He recently hailed Catholic Charities workers as “agents of hope” who for years have stood with migrants, refugees and the poor.
That encouragement from Rome has galvanized Catholics on the ground.
“The Church cannot stay silent before injustice,” Leo told a group of American faithful earlier this year. “You stand with me. And I stand with you.”
True to those words, as the White House strikes at the Church’s outreach, the Church is answering with an unambiguous no.
The clash between the Trump-Vance regime and Pope Leo’s Church has now reached a dramatic peak.
By defunding a Catholic charity for the “crime” of sheltering the vulnerable, the White House is effectively picking a fight with the Gospel itself.
But the Catholic Church in America, inspired by a pope who won’t back down, seems prepared to fight that battle.
“Human dignity is not dependent on a person’s papers,” one conservative bishop said recently, challenging the administration’s rhetoric.
In plain terms: the Church will continue feeding, clothing, and defending those at the margins, whether or not it has federal money to do so.
And if this presidency tries to shutter Catholic ministries out of spite, it will find a united Church — laity, clergy, and pope — resolved to stand in the way.
President Trump may believe he’s teaching Pope Leo XIV and the bishops a lesson by hitting their budgets. Instead, he may be awakening a sleeping giant.
The coming weeks will show whether this unprecedented assault on Catholic charities will succeed, or whether it only strengthens the Church’s resolve to “be a Church of the Beatitudes… making room for the little ones” even under government pressure.
One thing is certain: neither Pope Leo nor the people of God in America are inclined to give Caesar the last word.
Letters from Leo is open to anyone who wants to be informed and inspired by our pope — and to turn that inspiration into action that leaves America and the world more just, less cold, and more alive with hope.
If you want to support our mission during this holiday season, here’s how you can help:
- Subscribe as a paid member to receive exclusive posts about the life and formation of Pope Leo and help sustain this newsletter.
- Donate with a one-time gift to fuel this project’s mission.
- Share this post (and Letters from Leo) with a friend who might enjoy it.
Whether you give $0, $1, or $1,000, your presence here matters — no matter your faith or your politics.
Thank you for reading. I’ll see you on the road.
Prefer A One-Time Gift? Donate Here
